One certain melody has been lingering in my mind this week, and no, it doesn't come from the singer's new album. It comes by a far more accomplished artist: a children's entertainer. The song is named Big Feelings and its words go: “Big feelings are OK / I’m here to stay with your big feelings.”
The Rise of Intense Reactions On the Internet
Due to the movement for conscious parenting, the concept of “big feelings” has turned into big money digitally, and generally I welcome that. Being a parent, powerful emotions are difficult to ignore: you're feeling them, the youngster in your house is having them and, in one of the most significant departures for us as a humanity, so are countless other children on your digital streams.
Truly, footage of babies and children crying is so commonplace on some platforms that many parents see it as normal. I avoid TikTok and my Instagram algorithm is mostly centered around broth and magic, but when a friend mentioned that she thought the phenomenon disturbing, not to mention morally dubious, I watched some of the clips myself.
My Observations: Children at Their Most Fragile
My findings was video after video of children at their most fragile. Crying, yelling, shrieking, and sometimes acting out. I have certainly been observant to these situations in my own house, but watching a different child experiencing it feels excruciatingly uncomfortable, particularly when that child is not receiving solace by their own parent. Most unacceptable is a category of video in which mothers subject their children to nasal suction while their little one sobs and yells right into the recording. It should be said that many of the videos are different, and yet there is nevertheless something horrible about them all.
In Cases Where Big Feelings Aren't Traumatic
Naturally, “big feelings” are not always wholly traumatic. When your child is lying on the sidewalk heartbroken at the realisation that sweets don't last forever it can be hard to remain serious. Many of us have been told tales of notably unforgettable tantrums of our own. Mine involved shouting “GIVE ME ALL YOUR MONEY!” in the foyer of the a cultural center in the heart of the city. Gently mocking your child about a instance they had a tantrum, or laughing about it with your partner once they have gone to bed, is acceptable. Recording a child in a moment of weakness and uploading it to the online world for all to see lacking approval is a different matter entirely.
Unpleasant Phenomena and Humiliation
Furthermore you have the phenomena that are just disturbing, such as one that featured shocking babies out of crying by throwing a slice of cheese at their heads, or breaking an egg on them. That kind of content appears aimed at humiliating children. In a report for the a newspaper, a writer commented: “The eeriest part of these videos [is that] the parents are scarcely interacting with their kids. Instead they are focused on a digital version of their children that they are disseminating online. And they are enjoying their control over that image.”
The Justification of Learning Moments
There are video creators who would abhor this sort of content. They assert that they are filming their children at their most fragile not to ridicule them, but because they are aiming to create teachable moments – “just look at how calmly and effectively I was able to defuse this child’s tantrum using these methods”. Some even aim to avoid certain criticism. “This video is shared to teach and increase understanding – not for support or opinions”, a particular clip, posted by an page managed by a paediatrician, reportedly states. The message that follows is one of the most self-praising nonsense I have read on the internet. “If you haven't experienced the life, refrain from criticizing the moment.”
An Inquiry of Obligation
Why not you refrain from sharing the moment? I can't help but ask. Because I certainly critique these people. The impression I get, when I observe a video of a youngster in anguish, whether their parent is showing solace or not, is a failure of responsibility – the responsibility to be present for your child. And I ponder what implication it communicates, that when your child begins showing a “big feeling”, you reach for your device. What does that say to your child about their entirely expected emotions? “Sharing real moments is part of the learning”, apparently.
Thoughts on Modern Upbringing
When my husband and I start touring schools for our son, it’s hard not to think about how strategies to parenting have shifted since we were children. There is an greater recognition of the fact that “big feelings” are par for the course for small children. Currently a lot of adults attempt to acknowledge those emotions and give children a secure environment in which to share their feelings. But despite what the gentle parenting influencers claim, I do not think you can really offer a safe space for your child if you are capturing their instances of vulnerability and violating their confidentiality and dignity in the process. Truthfully, I don’t think these people have much to instruct any of us about parenting.
An Ending Question
Certain individuals who will consider that harsh, who would recoil from the fact that in particular aspects I’d sooner put a cheese slice on my son's forehead for a giggle than take advantage of his distress as a teachable moment for clicks. But to them I would state this: if “all behavior is message”, what, specifically, are these caregivers attempting to communicate?